Technology assessment criteria
|
Criterion/ significance |
Level 0 |
Level 1-2 |
Level 3-4 |
Level 5-6 |
|
A: Investigate |
The student does not reach a standard described by any of the descriptors. |
States the problem. Collects information from sources to investigate the problem. Lists some specifications. |
Describes the problem and mentions its relevance. Selects and analyzes information from acknowledged sources. Describes a test to evaluate the product/solution. |
Explains the problem and discusses its relevance. Is critical and evaluates information from a broad range of sources. Describes detailed methods to test and evaluate the product/solution. |
|
B: design |
The student does not reach a standard described by any of the descriptors. |
Generates one design and makes some attempt to justify it against the design conditions, requirements and restrictions (“design specifications.”) |
Generates a few designs, being able to justify the choice of one of them, and evaluates them against design specifications. |
Generates a range of feasible designs, each evaluated against design specifications. Student can choose one design and justify the choice critically. |
|
C: plan |
The student does not reach a standard described by any of the descriptors. |
Produces a plan that contains some details of the steps and/or resources required. |
Produces a plan that contains several logical steps that include resources and time. Makes some attempt to evaluate the plan. |
Produces a detailed plan that has many logical steps, addressing the use of resources and time. Student critically evaluates the plan and justifies any modification to design. |
|
D: create |
The student does not reach a standard described by any of the descriptors. |
Considers the plan and creates at least part of a product/solution. |
Uses appropriate techniques and equipment. Follows the plan and mentions modifications. Product solution is good. |
Competent use of appropriate techniques and equipment. Follows the plan, justifying all modifications. Product/ solution is the best the student can produce. |
|
E: evaluate |
The student does not reach a standard described by any of the descriptors. |
Evaluates the product solution or their performance. Makes some attempt to test the solution. |
Evaluates the product solution and own performance, making suggestions for improvement. Tests the solution against design specifications. |
Evaluates the success of the solution objectively, based on results of testing and views of users. Includes suggestions for each stage of the process. Evaluates the impact of the solution. |
|
F: attitudes in technology |
The student does not reach a standard described by any of the descriptors. |
Occasionally exhibits a satisfactory standard in their motivation, independence and a positive attitude. Rarely shows cooperation and respect for others and for safety. |
Frequently exhibits a satisfactory standard in motivation, independence and a positive attitude. Sometimes shows cooperation and respect for others and for safety. |
Consistently exhibits motivation, independence and a positive attitude. Often shows cooperation and respect for others and for safety. |